Dear
Supreme Court justices: When I heard about the McCutcheon v. Federal Election
Commission ruling, it made me plotz. I’m a rabbi, so I know much more about the
Talmud than about torts. But if there’s any group that can compete with
scholars of constitutional law, it’s rabbis. Your recent decision was all about
the First Amendment and free speech. As I understand it, legal scholars have
interpreted that word “speech” to include “political expression.” So far, I’m
with you. I think the freedom of being able to talk politics without fear of
reprisal, whether you are a mighty politician or a lowly voter, is A-OK. But
when you said that political expression is the same as a campaign contribution,
you lost me. The First Amendment protects the right of every citizen to speak
freely. It does not protect the right to give money to politics. Money is not
the same as speech. If you want to equate money with something, consider
equating it with influence, not speech.
Read
Rabbi Justus
Baird’s (Dean of Auburn Theological Seminary) commentary at -- http://www.religionnews.com/2014/04/08/commentary-free-speech-just-got-expensive/
Comments
Post a Comment