Skip to main content

Deuteronomy may be the last book of the Torah, but it is not Judaism's last word.


 This article from "The Girl and the Drash": 

And the man that will act willfully, not listen to the priest who stands there to sever God, or to the judge, that man shall die, and you shall destroy the evil from among Israel. (Duet. 17:12)
T
After the temple is destroyed and the court in Jerusalem is abandoned, the early rabbis read this passage and saw nothing of their world within it. Forced to abandon temple Judaism, they begin the incredible task of creating a Judaism that walks off the Torah scroll and finds shelter in the Talmud's folio. For this new Judaism to work, the everyday litigant and the highest court in Jerusalem are replaced with rabbinic scholars and the study halls of Yavneh, the first city of rabbinic Judaism. The litigant who does not obey the court is transformed into the rebellious elder, who does not obey the rabbinic majority.  

However, unlike the insubordinate litigant, the rebellious elder is not killed. In the Babylonian Talmud, his dissent is tolerated, assuming his argument is good . . . The Talmudic construction of the rebellious elder is incongruous with the original intent in Devarim (Deuteronomy). While in Devarim, the law demands obedience at the cost of death; the Talmud's version expressly justifies intellectual dissent. The Talmud establishes an anti-authoritarian ontology under the guise of establishing authority.

Read complete article at –
http://www.patheos.com/Resources/Additional-Resources/Dealing-with-Deuteronomy-Anna-Batler-08-31-2011.html

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why did they lay their coats at Saul's feet?

The witnesses, laying their coats at the feet of Saul, were the men that would cast the first stones at Stephen in Acts 7. Why did they all lay their coats at Saul’s feet? The Talmud contains a very interesting account of the act of stoning that may provide the answer. “When the trial was over, they take him [the condemned person] out to be stoned. The place of stoning was at a distance from the court, as it is said, ‘Take out the one who has cursed.’ [i] A man stands at the entrance of the court; in his hand is a signaling flag [Hebrew   sudarin = sudar , ‘scarf, sweater’]. A horseman was stationed far away but within sight of him. If one [of the judges] says, ‘I have something [more] to say in his favor,’ he [the signaler] waves the   sudarin , and the horseman runs and stops them [from stoning him]. Even if [the condemned person] himself says, ‘I have something to say in my favor,’ they bring him back, even four of five times, only provided that there is some substance to...
Post a Comment
Read more

Are Saul and Paul the Same Person?

There has always been some confusion over whether Saul and Paul is the same person. The confusion begins in the Book of Acts. ● “Then Barnabas departed for Tarsus to seek Saul . . . he brought him to Antioch . . . for a whole year they taught a great many people. And the disciples were first called ‘ Christians ’ in Antioch .” ( Acts 11:25-26 ) ● “ Then Agrippa said to Paul , `You almost persuade me to become a Christian .’” ( Acts 26:28) ● “ Then Saul , who also  is called   Paul . . . ” ( Acts 13:9a ) Based on the three verses above, we would assume they are references to the same person – but is he the Paul we read about in the Epistles? The name “ Saul ” doesn’t appear in the Epistles. In order to answer that question we must examine the stories of the “ conversion experiences ” of Saul in Acts and Paul in Galatians . Pay close attention to the time periods and places mentioned in both accounts. Saul’s experience is found in Acts 9 and...
Post a Comment
Read more

Should 21st Century Christians Do What the Jewish Jesus Taught?

  When Jesus taught his followers about the Great Day of Judgment, he said that the entire population of the world will be separated into two groups – people in one group will be sent into everlasting punishment and the people in the other group will go into eternal life . The standard they will be judged by is the TOV Standard . Continue reading at - https://mailchi.mp/8f6a8edc408a/should-21st-century-christians-do-what-the-jewish-jesus-taught
Post a Comment
Read more